InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Cost of handling biometric refusals and exceptions with 500 employees

Exceptions to biometrics are not a marginal situation: refusals, withdrawn consents and false rejections come back to HR, security and IT as tickets. Below we break the administrative time down by type of case and count its cost in a sample calculation for a plant with 500 employees.

40
exceptional cases a year (sample calculation)
Source: sample calculation
60 h
annual administrative time
Source: sample calculation
PLN 4,800
annual cost at PLN 80 per hour
Source: sample calculation

Three types of exceptions at a plant with biometrics

In practice exceptions fall into refusals of consent at implementation, withdrawals of consent during employment, and false rejections at check-in. Each type reaches a different department and requires different evidence.

Employee consent as a basis for processing biometric data raises doubts because of the imbalance between the parties to an employment relationship, so it requires particular caution and a genuine alternative. Since an alternative must exist, handling it is a permanent cost item, not an exception to the rule.

  • Refusal at implementation: the employee does not give consent, so they must be issued a card or a QR badge.
  • Withdrawal of consent: HR switches the entry method, and IT deletes the template.
  • False rejection: the reader does not recognise the finger (damaged skin, gloves, dirt), security lets the person in manually and records the event.

Calculation assumptions for 500 employees

For a mid-sized plant we assume 500 employees, of whom 8 percent a year report an exception, that is 40 cases. The time of one case is 90 minutes in total across HR, security and IT, and the hourly rate of administrative handling is PLN 80.

These figures are assumptions for a purchasing spreadsheet, not data from a specific plant. In a plant with a lot of protective gloves the share of false rejections will be higher than in an office.

Breakdown of 40 exceptional cases a year

Breakdown of 40 exceptional cases a yearPie chart: 8 refusals, 7 withdrawn consents and 25 false rejections a year.Refusals at implementation: 8 cases (20%)Withdrawn consents: 7 cases (17.5%)False rejections: 25 cases (62.5%)40casesRefusals at implementation8 cases (20%)Withdrawn consents7 cases (17.5%)False rejections25 cases (62.5%)
Source: Sample calculation based on the assumptions in the Assumptions section

Calculation: refusals, withdrawals and false rejections

Of the 40 cases a year, the distribution adopted in the calculation is 15 refusals at implementation and withdrawn consents, and 25 false rejections requiring intervention. The first group requires formalities: issuing a card or a badge, updating the records, and information under Article 13 GDPR. The second is the work of security at the gate.

The total time is 60 hours a year, and at a rate of PLN 80 the cost is PLN 4,800. We do not include here the downtime of employees waiting to enter during a fault, because it depends on the shift and the time of check-ins.

How to reduce the cost of exceptions without changing the rules

The first way is a parallel path from day zero: an encrypted card or a badge with a unique, random QR token. Cancelling issues a new code and the badge history is kept, so a replacement does not require changes to personal data.

The second way is limiting biometrics to narrow zones. A typical conclusion from the impact assessment for employee entry control is: for most areas of the plant a card or a QR code is sufficient. Fewer points with biometrics means fewer rejections.

The third way is recording by QR scan: scans at the gate create the mobile time record (mRCP) and an evacuation list refreshed every 13 seconds, so a manual admission leaves no gaps in attendance.

Annual hours of exception handling

Annual hours of exception handlingBar chart of handling hours: refusals 12, withdrawals 10.5, false rejections 37.5 hours.010203040hRefusals: 12 h12 hRefusalsWithdrawals: 10.5 h10.5 hWithdrawalsFalse rejections: 37.5 h37.5 hFalse rejections
Source: Sample calculation: number of cases x 1.5 h

What to do with data after a refusal or withdrawal of consent

The data minimisation principle in Article 5(1)(c) GDPR requires that data be limited to what is necessary. After a refusal or a withdrawal of consent the template is redundant and should be deleted from the reader, the access control server and the backups. It is worth attaching proof of deletion to the documentation.

InnerWeb does not store templates, because it receives check-in events from the access control system in the form of a person identifier and a timestamp. The REST API with JWT and webhooks make it possible to pass deactivation information on to other systems, but ready-made connectors to specific client systems require implementation work.

Example calculation

Annual cost of handling biometric exceptions

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Number of employees500 people
Share of exceptions8 percent per year
Time of one case90 minutes
Hourly rate80 PLN/h

Result: 40 cases x 1.5 h = 60 h a year, that is PLN 4,800. Distribution: 8 refusals (12 h), 7 withdrawals (10.5 h), 25 false rejections (37.5 h).

Note: Sample calculation based on the assumptions above; it is not an offer or a guarantee of a result. Individual quotation.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Does every refusal require separate documentation?

Yes, it is worth recording the refusal, the alternative provided and the lack of consequences for the employee, which gives evidence for an audit.

Does a QR scan replace the reader in case of a fault?

Yes, as a fallback path: a scan on the security panel gives a verdict on whether the person may be on site, and scans at the gate feed the time record.

Can false rejections be eliminated?

Not completely. They can be reduced by keeping the range of biometric zones narrow and by having a backup path.

Sources

Want to count the exceptions at your plant?

We will match the assumptions with your data on the workforce and entry points. Book a conversation or a demo.

Let's talk