InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Biometrics versus encrypted cards: total cost of ownership at a mid-sized plant

A purchasing department comparing biometrics with encrypted cards rarely sees the full picture, because the price of a reader is only part of the bill. Below we break the total cost of ownership into components and show a sample calculation for a plant with 500 employees, with explicit assumptions.

500
employees in the sample calculation
Source: sample calculation
40
exceptional cases per year with biometrics (8 percent)
Source: sample calculation
60 h
exception handling per year at 40 cases of 90 min
Source: sample calculation

What the total cost of ownership consists of

The total cost of ownership of access control is the sum of one-off and recurring expenses over the whole period of use, usually five years. The device itself is often a smaller part of the bill than administration and compliance.

With biometrics there are items that cards do not have: a data protection impact assessment, GDPR training, a template retention policy, and handling refusals and false rejections. With cards there is the cost of media, personalisation and replacement after loss.

  • Readers and controllers: purchase, installation, cabling.
  • Media: encrypted DESFire-type cards or badges with a QR code.
  • DPIA and compliance documentation before deployment (Article 35 GDPR).
  • Training for employees and administrators.
  • Handling exceptions: refusals, withdrawn consents, re-registration.
  • Maintenance, licences and updates.

Why the DPIA and GDPR obligations are a cost item

Article 35 GDPR requires an impact assessment before processing that is likely to result in a high risk to the rights of individuals, including large-scale processing of special categories of data. Workforce biometrics meets these criteria, so the DPIA is practically unavoidable.

In addition there is the information obligation under Article 13 GDPR, the measures under Article 32 (encryption, access control) and the demonstration of necessity under Article 22(1b) of the Polish Labour Code. Each of these tasks means hours of work for the data protection officer, a lawyer or IT, even when the company's own team does them.

Annual hours of exception handling: biometrics vs cards

Annual hours of exception handling: biometrics vs cardsComparison of exception handling hours in the scenario of biometrics everywhere and the scenario of cards with biometrics in one zone.0102030h/yearBiometrics everywhere (Refusals and withdrawn consents): 30 h/year30 h/yearCards with biometrics in one zone (Refusals and withdrawn consents): 4 h/year4 h/yearRefusals and withdrawn consentsBiometrics everywhere (False rejections): 30 h/year30 h/yearCards with biometrics in one zone (False rejections): 4 h/year4 h/yearFalse rejections
  • Biometrics everywhere
  • Cards with biometrics in one zone
Source: Sample calculation based on the assumptions in the Calculation section

Indicative cost ranges

Indicative ranges from deployments in 2025-2026; individual quotation. A biometric reader usually costs several times more than a contactless card reader, but the decisive factor is the number of entry points and the cabling. Encrypted cards are the unit cost of the medium multiplied by the number of employees, plus a reserve for replacements.

InnerWeb does not sell readers or access control cards, so these items are bought by the client from the access control system supplier. InnerWeb adds the software layer: it receives check-in events from the access control system via a webhook and links them with qualifications, permits, attendance and time records, and this layer costs the same regardless of the reader technology.

Sample calculation for 500 employees

The calculation below assumes 6 entry points, a period of 5 years and two scenarios: biometric readers at all points, or encrypted cards at all points, with biometrics in only one narrow zone. The figures are assumptions for a purchasing spreadsheet, not a price list.

The biometric scenario requires more administrative time: with 500 employees and an assumed 8 percent of exceptions per year, that is 40 cases, each taking 90 minutes. The card scenario covers replacing lost cards and personalisation, estimated lower.

Purchasing conclusion and decision points

A typical conclusion from the impact assessment for employee entry control: for most areas of a plant a card or a QR code is sufficient, and biometrics is considered only for narrow zones of particular protection. The purchasing department should therefore ask not about the price of the reader, but about how many entry points actually require biometrics.

The second question is the exit from the system. A biometric template cannot be changed after a leak, because a body feature is permanent, while a card is replaced. This risk factor has no price in the spreadsheet, but it has one in the DPIA.

Example calculation

Annual cost of exception handling at a plant with 500 employees

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Number of employees500 people
Share of exceptions with biometrics everywhere8 percent per year
Time of one case90 minutes
Share of exceptions with cards and biometrics in a narrow zone1 percent per year
Hourly rate of administrative handling80 PLN/h

Result: Biometrics everywhere: 40 cases x 1.5 h = 60 h per year, that is PLN 4,800. Cards and narrow zone: 5 cases x 1.5 h = 7.5 h, that is PLN 600. Difference PLN 4,200 per year, excluding the costs of the DPIA and training.

Note: Sample calculation based on the assumptions above; it is not an offer or a guarantee of a result. Indicative ranges from deployments in 2025-2026; individual quotation.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Are encrypted cards cheaper than biometrics?

Usually yes in total cost of ownership, because the high costs of the DPIA and of handling refusals fall away. The final bill depends on the number of entry points and the media replacement policy.

Does InnerWeb sell readers?

No. InnerWeb is a software manufacturer and integrates with the client's existing access control system.

Does the software require a biometric template?

No. An event from the access control system may consist of a person identifier and a timestamp.

Sources

Comparing entry technologies for your plant?

We will help you put the costs side by side and show how the software layer links check-ins from the access control system with qualifications and permits. Book a conversation.

Let's talk