InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Cost of wrong delivery routes on plant grounds: a calculation

A driver who heads to the wrong warehouse blocks the access road, extends the stop and ties up security. The cost of one mistake is small, but across many deliveries a day it adds up over a year. We show a sample calculation with explicit assumptions and point to the share of that cost that driver voice navigation could recover.

PLN 72,000
annual cost of mistakes under sample assumptions
Source: sample calculation
PLN 36,000
recovered per year with mistakes reduced by half
Source: sample calculation

Where the cost of a wrong route comes from

A wrong route usually starts at the first junction behind the gate. The driver sees several directions and several signs, and heard the briefing once, often in a language that is not their own. They drive to the wrong warehouse, turn back, wait for the direction to change or call security.

The cost has several components: the time of the driver and the vehicle, the blocking of a plant road, the time of the security officer or dispatcher, and the delay of the next deliveries in the queue. The first component can be counted directly, while the others are worth at least estimating with your own data.

  • Time spent driving to the wrong place and back.
  • Blocked access road and delay for the vehicles behind.
  • Security or dispatcher time spent explaining and directing.
  • Risk of entering a zone the delivery is not allowed to enter.

Assumptions of the sample calculation

This is a sample calculation for a plant with a high number of deliveries a day. The assumed values do not come from a specific plant and are not the result of an implementation: replace them with your own data from the delivery notices, the security log or the online map.

We assumed 200 deliveries a day, 250 working days a year, 4% of deliveries with a wrong route, 12 minutes of lost time per mistake and PLN 180 per hour of stop covering the driver, the vehicle, the road and the handling time. We also assumed that voice navigation reduces mistakes by half.

Annual cost of wrong routes, sample calculation

Annual cost of wrong routes, sample calculationBefore and after chart: PLN 72,000 a year before, PLN 36,000 after reducing the number of mistakes by half.020,00040,00060,00080,000PLN per yearBefore: 72,000 PLN per year72,000BeforeAfter reduction by half: 36,000 PLN per year36,000After reduction by half
Source: Sample calculation on the assumptions listed in the Assumptions section

Result of the calculation

At 4% wrong routes out of 200 deliveries a day, there are 8 mistakes a day. At 12 minutes of lost time per mistake, that is 96 minutes, or 1.6 hours a day. Multiplied by PLN 180 this gives PLN 288 a day, and over 250 working days PLN 72,000 a year.

If voice navigation reduces the number of mistakes by half, the recovered PLN 36,000 a year is a sample value under these assumptions. The result is modest, but it does not include costs that are harder to count: the queue at the gate, the risk of entering the wrong zone and the time of security.

How the result changes with other data

The result is linear in the number of deliveries, the share of mistakes and the time lost. With a share of mistakes twice as high, that is 8%, the amount doubles. For a plant with one gate and a few dozen deliveries a day, the same calculation gives proportionally less.

What has to be in place for the saving to be real

Voice navigation is not GPS and not live routing. It relies on an editable matrix of directions for the warehouses and leads to the warehouses covered by the matrix. A delivery must have the target dock code entered, because the dock code defines the warehouse.

Location relies on signals from several BLE beacons averaged on the map, without GPS, and plant roads are fitted with beacons roughly every 100 m. The driver must carry a locator, and the messages are available in one of 10 languages. Without beacon coverage along the route, the effect will be smaller than in the calculation.

How to measure the share of mistakes at your plant

The most reliable method is to compare the planned and the actual route. The preview of the delivery route on the online map shows the locator's path from entry up to the current moment, and the route points are stored separately, so the route can be reconstructed even for an archived delivery.

For two weeks, count the deliveries in which the route entered a section not matching the target warehouse, and measure the additional time. From these two numbers you will build your own assumptions and replace the sample 4% and 12 minutes with them.

Example calculation

Cost of wrong routes under sample assumptions

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Deliveries a day200 deliveries
Working days250 days a year
Share of wrong routes4 %
Time lost per mistake12 min
Cost of an hour of stop180 PLN
Reduction of mistakes by navigation50 %

Result: 8 mistakes a day, 1.6 hours of time lost a day, PLN 288 a day, PLN 72,000 a year; with a reduction by half, PLN 36,000 a year recovered.

Note: Sample calculation on explicit assumptions, not the result of an implementation. Replace the assumptions with your plant's own data; implementation pricing is individual.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Are the amounts in the calculation the result of an implementation?

No. It is a sample calculation on explicit assumptions. Each plant sets its own assumptions based on delivery notices, the security log and the route preview.

Will voice navigation eliminate all mistakes?

No. The calculation assumes a reduction by half. Navigation leads to warehouses covered by the matrix and requires beacon coverage along the route.

Where can the share of wrong routes be taken from?

From the delivery route preview on the online map: routes are stored, so they can be reconstructed even for archived deliveries.

Let's calculate it for your plant

Enter your own data into the calculation and let us go through how many route mistakes voice navigation can reduce at your site.

Let's talk