InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Cost of Auditing Duplicate Beacons and the Field Visit

Auditing duplicate identifiers takes a few hours at a computer and one visit to the site, while wrong routes cost time with every delivery. The arithmetic is different from what intuition suggests: the most expensive option is often not auditing at all. Below is the structure of the work, data from a real plant, and a sample calculation with explicit assumptions.

151 of 651
jumps disappeared after excluding one beacon
Source: plant record
840 PLN
sample cost of the audit, one-off
Source: sample calculation

What the Audit of Duplicate Identifiers Costs

The audit consists of three tasks: analysing jumps in the route data, establishing which beacon is duplicated, and a field visit in which the identifier of one of the physical devices is changed. The first two are done by the system administrator without going onto the hall floor.

A jump is defined as a point more than 55 m away from the previous one, after which the next point returns to less than 21 m from that previous point. This definition makes detection automatic and does not require reviewing every route by hand.

Real Plant Data: 151 of 651 Jumps

At one plant, 651 route jumps were detected. Of these, 151 were the return path of a single beacon and disappeared once that beacon was excluded from positioning. That is just under 23 percent of jumps removed by one change in the database, without entering the hall.

The budget conclusion is clear: the first hour of an analyst's work can remove a large share of the errors. The remainder requires finding the causes, which is cleanup work, not a hardware investment.

Sample cost: one-off audit versus a month without an audit

Sample cost: one-off audit versus a month without an auditChart: audit cost of 840 PLN once versus 2,640 PLN per month for wrong routes.0100020003000PLNAudit (one-off): Cost: 840 PLN840 PLNAudit (one-off)No audit (monthly): Cost: 2640 PLN2640 PLNNo audit (monthly)
Source: Sample calculation based on the assumptions in the Calculation section

Temporary Exclusion and Its Price

Excluding a duplicated identifier means changing its major number to a value that no device transmits. Position, minor and location stay unchanged, so restoring it is a matter of changing one number. The cost of the operation is a few minutes of administrator time.

The price is different: the exclusion applies to both twin devices, including the working one, so the navigation point is lost until the field visit. The longer the wait for the visit, the longer the hall stays less well covered.

Field Visit: How Long It Takes and What Affects It

The location of the duplicated device is determined from the data. The centre of the cluster of distant readings is converted into coordinates using the georeferencing of the hall with the PUWG92 grid convergence correction. Without this correction the point is off by tens of metres, the technician searches in the wrong place and the visit gets longer.

A correctly indicated location reduces the visit to a single intervention: locating the device, changing its identifier and entering the record in the installation register. Inactive spare entries are not deleted from the database, because the device may start transmitting again.

Route jumps at one plant

Route jumps at one plantBar chart: 651 detected route jumps and 151 removed by excluding one beacon.0200400600800jumpsDetected: 651 jumps651 jumpsDetectedRemoved by one change: 151 jumps151 jumpsRemoved by one change
Source: Feature documentation: 651 jumps detected, 151 of them disappeared after excluding one beacon

Sample Calculation: Audit Versus Wrong Routes

Assumptions: 4 hours of data analysis, a 3-hour field visit including travel across the hall, an hourly rate of 120 PLN, 20 deliveries per day affected by a jump, 3 minutes of manual route correction per delivery, and 22 working days per month. The cost of the audit is 7 hours times 120 PLN, which is 840 PLN once. The cost of not auditing: 20 times 3 minutes is 60 minutes per day, or 22 hours per month, about 2,640 PLN.

The result shows the method, not a promise: under these assumptions the audit pays for itself in the first month. With different data the result will change, so it is worth putting in your own figures.

Example calculation

Sample Calculation: Audit of Duplicate Identifiers

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Data analysis4 hours
Field visit3 hours
Hourly rate120 PLN/hour
Deliveries affected by a jump20 per day
Manual correction of one route3 min
Working days22 per month

Result: Audit 840 PLN once; no audit about 2,640 PLN per month (22 hours of work).

Note: Sample calculation based on the assumptions above. The actual result depends on the number of duplicated identifiers and the scale of deliveries; individual quotation.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Does the audit require stopping the hall?

No. Data analysis and temporary exclusion are done from within the system. The field visit covers one device.

Will old routes improve after the audit?

No. Route points are unchangeable records from the moment of the signal, so the fix applies to future deliveries.

Why not delete the spare entries?

Because an inactive device may start transmitting again. The entry stays in the database, and its activity is visible in the statistics.

Calculate the cost of wrong routes in your plant

We will review your route data for jumps and duplicate identifiers. Book a conversation or a demo.

Let's talk