InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Checklist of terms before an access control system review

A review of an access control system often starts with a dispute over words: security speaks of a card, IT of a credential, and the integrator of a controller. Before participants sit down at the table, it is worth agreeing on the meaning of a few terms. Below is a checklist with comments that shortens the meeting and reduces misunderstandings.

7 B
length of the UID in DESFire EV3
128 bit
AES in the OSDP Secure Channel

Why it is worth agreeing on terms before the meeting

A review of an access control system brings together people from different departments: security, IT, health and safety, purchasing and the integrator. Each of them uses the same words with a different meaning, so half the meeting goes on establishing what is being discussed. A shared set of terms, sent in advance, saves that time.

The terms below answer the questions that come up most often at reviews: how a card differs from its number, where the keys are kept, how a reader talks to a controller, and who in the plant decides when entry is allowed.

Terms for the carrier and the keys

The first group concerns what is on the card and who manages it.

UID

The UID is the unique identifier of the card chip. A DESFire EV3 has a 7-byte UID and an optional random identifier that protects the holder's privacy. The random identifier does not reveal the fixed UID on reading and is not a key derivation mechanism. A system that bases authentication only on the UID can be fooled with cards whose number can be changed.

Key diversification

Diversification means that the card key is calculated from a master key and the card's unique UID, so a leaked key of one card does not open the others. It is described, among others, by the key derivation function in NIST SP 800-108.

SAM module

The SAM module in a reader stores the master keys in a protected chip and performs card authentication, so the keys never leave the reader. At the review it is worth asking whether the readers have a SAM and who manages the keys stored in it.

Technical figures of the terms on the list

Technical figures of the terms on the listBar chart: UID 7 bytes, card AES 128 bits, OSDP Secure Channel 128 bits050100150wartośćDESFire EV3 UID (bytes): 7 wartość7DESFire EV3 UID (bytes)Card AES (bits): 128 wartość128Card AES (bits)OSDP Secure Channel (bits): 128 wartość128OSDP Secure Channel (bits)
Source: NXP MIFARE DESFire EV3; study on the OSDP protocol (whitepapers.axis.com)

Terms for the link and control

The second group concerns the path of the signal from the reader to the decision.

Wiegand and OSDP

Wiegand sends data from the reader to the controller in plain text, without encryption and without authentication, so the credential can be intercepted and replayed. OSDP runs on an RS-485 line and is a bidirectional protocol: a command and its response confirm delivery of the message. In installation mode OSDP data flows in plain text, and the Secure Channel encryption (AES-128) has to be explicitly enabled.

Controller and schedule

The controller is the device that, on the basis of a read and the rules, decides whether to let someone through. The schedule sets on which days and at which hours a given group of people has the right to pass. An OSDP controller constantly supervises the reader's status, which makes it possible to detect its disconnection or tampering; Wiegand does not offer such supervision.

Comment on the checklist

The list below is meant to be sent to participants before the meeting. It does not require technical knowledge from them, only agreement on the meanings. Each item can be ticked after a short conversation, and any disagreements are recorded as topics to clarify at the review.

InnerWeb is a software producer: it does not manufacture or replace readers and access control cards, but integrates with the client's existing access control system. For that reason the terms on the list serve the conversation about integration, not about replacing devices.

Checklist

Video

Frequently asked questions

Who should receive this list before the review?

All participants: security, IT, health and safety, purchasing and the integrator. The list does not require technical knowledge, only agreement on the meanings of the terms.

Is OSDP always encrypted?

No. In installation mode data flows in plain text, and the Secure Channel with AES-128 has to be explicitly enabled. It is worth checking on each reader.

Does the list apply only to InnerWeb systems?

No. It applies to any access control system that InnerWeb integrates with, because we do not manufacture readers or cards.

Sources

Let us prepare the review together

We will send participants the list of terms and discuss the integration with your access control system. Contact us.

Let's talk