InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Which level to assign a risk to: hall, area, line or place

The risk catalogue is hierarchical, so the same hazard can be assigned to several levels of the map. A level that is too high floods the printout with risks that do not concern a specific job, while a level that is too low requires many assignments. Below are the rules for choosing the level and avoiding repetitions on the permit printout.

5
risk sections on the permit printout
Source: feature card
4
levels of the location hierarchy
Source: feature card

How the system assembles risks on the printout

Risks are assigned to locations at every level: hall, area, line, place, and also to the type of dangerous work. The permit printout assembles them in five sections: risks common to permits, the location hierarchy, additional locations, the dangerous work type, and risks added by the requester.

A risk is never printed twice on the printout. Sections 1 to 4 collect risk identifiers, and the section of added risks omits what has already been shown. This is a safeguard against duplicates, but it does not release you from thinking about the assignment level: a risk assigned too high will appear on every permit in that hall.

The basic rule: the lowest level at which the hazard is real

Assign a risk to the lowest level at which the hazard occurs regardless of the type of work. If the noise affects the whole hall during every job, assign it to the hall. If it occurs only at one press on one line, assign it to that line or to the place. This way a worker on another line does not receive a warning that does not concern them.

The opposite mistake is assigning a risk to many places separately when it concerns the whole line. The number of assignments then grows, and every change requires many clicks. The hierarchy exists so that one assignment at a higher level covers everything below it.

Example: number of assignments of a noise risk in one hall

Example: number of assignments of a noise risk in one hallComparison: 12 separate assignments for places versus 1 assignment at hall level.02.557.51012.5assignmentsSeparately to 12 places: 12 assignments12Separately to 12 placesOne at hall level: 1 assignments1One at hall level
Source: Sample calculation: a hall with 12 places covered by the same noise risk

Two examples: noise and forklift traffic

Noise is sometimes common to the whole hall, but sometimes local. A hall with a uniform noise background from ventilation and process lines: the risk sits at the hall level. A hall with one loud pressing line: the risk sits at the line level, and the hall is left without that entry.

Forklift traffic usually concerns entire transport routes, so it is often an area or hall level. If forklifts drive only in the loading zone, assign the risk to the zone area. In both cases, check on the printout whether the risk appears once, in the right section of the location hierarchy.

  • General noise for the whole hall: hall level.
  • Noise at a specific line: line level.
  • Forklift traffic on transport routes: area or hall level.
  • A hazard at a single device: place level.

How to check assignments on the map

The 3D map editor shows, in the left column, the risks of all levels on the path of the selected node: hall, area, line, place. Click a workstation to see the complete list of risks that the worker will see. In the editor the risks are a list, one per row, with a pictogram, a name and protective measures.

Good practice is to review the paths for several representative places after the catalogue is loaded: a place by the entrance, a place on a line, and a place at a special device. If the list seems too long, some risks are probably assigned too high.

Separating location risks from work risks

Location risks describe the place, while dangerous work type risks describe the kind of activity, for example fire work or work at height. Do not move work risks to a location just because such work happens there. Otherwise every worker in that location will receive a warning that concerns only a specific activity.

Instead, let the printout combine both sources: the location with its risks and the work type with its own risks. The duplicate will be removed automatically, and the items will remain organised.

Checklist

Video

Frequently asked questions

Can a risk appear on the printout twice?

No. Sections 1 to 4 collect risk identifiers, and the section of added risks omits what has already been shown.

Where can I see all the risks for a place?

In the left column of the 3D map editor, which shows the risks of all levels on the path of the selected node: hall, area, line, place.

How are the printout sections built?

The printout has five sections: common risks, the location hierarchy, additional locations, the dangerous work type, and risks added by the requester.

Let's review the assignment levels in your hall

During the demo we will walk through the risk path for selected places and check whether the permit printout does not repeat items.

Let's talk