Why references without names are the norm at critical plants
At critical infrastructure, energy and chemical plants, the name of a site in a supplier's materials can be sensitive information. Confidentiality agreements forbid disclosing it, and a client list could make it easier to identify security arrangements. A supplier that respects such restrictions cannot show a logo, but can show the type of deployment, the scale and the evidence.
For procurement this changes the way of working: instead of asking who the reference is, we ask what the reference is and how to check it without a name. The answer depends on what evidence the supplier can provide under NDA and what it discloses publicly.
Entry conditions: licence, liability insurance, technical capability
In tenders for a location system for a critical plant, the entry condition is often a licence for technical security, liability insurance covering the protection of persons and property, technical capability (with subcontractors held to the same requirements) and a reference of similar scale. Such conditions are verified with a document, not an opinion.
InnerWeb holds the MSWiA licence L-0023/25. The buyer can ask for a copy of the document and check its scope. For liability insurance it is worth requesting a policy with a guarantee sum and a scope covering the protection of persons and property, not only general civil liability.
- licence for technical security: number, scope, validity date
- liability insurance policy: scope of protection of persons and property, guarantee sum, period
- technical capability: description of the team, experience, subcontractors
- reference of similar scale: type, measure, year
Scale in beacons: references and the whole installed base
Scale measure: beacons or people
The most common mistake in assessing references is comparing different measures. A reference for 10,000 people does not say how many beacons were installed, and a reference for 5,000 beacons does not say how many people it covers. The number of people and the number of beacons are different measures of scale.
For a location system the technical measure is the number of beacons and the area, because they determine the complexity of installation and maintenance. For a personnel records system the measure is the number of users. The buyer should state in the tender which measure interests them, and if both, request both.
How InnerWeb answers the question about scale
As a reference for beacon scale, InnerWeb points to an urban deployment: 11,000 beacons in 95 facilities over more than 120,000 m2 with accuracy below 1.5 m, and an industrial reference with a network of about 600 beacons. These are two different types: the urban one shows breadth and the number of facilities, the industrial one shows the plant environment.
In addition, the company has 16,000 beacons in installations, 20 implementations and pilots, 531 ha of monitored areas and 100% of pilots moving to implementation. When answering a tender, we give the measure separately for each reference and describe what it proves.
How to verify a reference without a name
Verification without a name rests on indirect evidence. The buyer can ask for an anonymised description of the deployment with the date, area and number of beacons, for confirmation from the client passed on by the supplier under NDA, or for a conversation with a reference user if the client agrees.
Accuracy can also be checked from measurements: a reference with accuracy below 1.5 m makes sense when the measurement method and the number of control points are given. A supplier that gives only a number without a method provides weaker evidence.
- anonymised description of the deployment: year, area, number of beacons
- accuracy measurement method and number of control points
- client confirmation passed on under NDA
- conversation with a reference user if the client gives consent
- formal documents: licence, liability insurance, CE declarations for devices
Answering functional requirements: met and partly met
A reference is not enough if the supplier cannot answer the requirements honestly. In one tender covering 19 functional requirements of a location system, the answer marked 18 as met and 1 as partly met, with a device variant. The required accuracy was 5 m inside buildings and 10 m on outdoor sites.
Such a result is more credible than a full set of answers saying "met". The buyer should check whether the variant for the partly met item has a description, a cost and a date, because this shows how the supplier treats its own limitations.
Recommendations for the procurement department
The recommendations below help turn the confidentiality of references into criteria that can be compared across offers.
- state in the tender which scale measure is required and how it should be confirmed
- accept anonymised references, but require the year, area and number of beacons
- request copies of the licence and the liability policy, because these are documents that can be checked
- treat a "partly met" answer with a variant as a sign of reliability
- assess scale from two references of different character, e.g. urban and industrial
- ask about the move from pilot to implementation, because it is proof that the client continued the cooperation
Video
Frequently asked questions
Can a supplier refuse to name a client?
Yes, if it is bound by confidentiality. In return the buyer can request an anonymised description with the year, area and number of beacons, as well as formal documents.
Are the number of people and the number of beacons comparable?
No, they are different scale measures. The buyer should state in the tender which measure interests them and request answers in the same unit.
Which documents should be checked before assessing references?
The licence for technical security, the liability insurance policy covering the protection of persons and property, and a description of technical capability including subcontractors held to the same requirements.
Preparing a tender for a location system?
We will provide an anonymised reference description and formal documents in a form the procurement department can compare across offers.
Let's talk