InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Objects without position: recommendations for the register

A data engineer migrating a plant register usually finds items whose position no source knows. Guessing coordinates is worse than admitting a gap. Below are recommendations on how to handle such a group so that the map does not lie and the gaps can be closed in a controlled way.

64
control points of the transformation check
Source: implementation card
0,01 m
maximum error after converting back
Source: implementation card

Where objects without position come from

Building materials plant registers contain objects that exist in the documentation but have no position on the map: old feeders, tanks, chambers, equipment taken out of service. Their names live on in permits and reports, so they cannot simply be deleted.

In addition, the coordinates of some locations are stored in the system of another view. A view without georeferencing cannot be a source of position at the plant: its numbers, without an anchor, rotation and scale, do not say where anything stands.

Recommendation 1: a shared Plant site area without geometry

Register objects without a known position go to the area Plant site, which has no geometry or point. They are invisible on the map until a position is assigned. This is a deliberate decision: the object is in the register and can be selected in the form, but the map does not pretend to know where it stands.

The alternative, placing a pin in the middle of the hall, gives a false sense of knowledge. The person accepting a permit would see a place that nobody has checked.

Example: number of objects without position by quarter

Example: number of objects without position by quarterLine chart: 90 objects at the start, then 62, 40, 22 and 10 in the following quarters.020406080100objectsStartQ1Q2Q3Q4Start: 90 objects90Q1: 62 objects62Q2: 40 objects40Q3: 22 objects22Q4: 10 objects10
Source: Example calculation based on the assumptions of this page: 90 objects at the start and a decline thanks to field work.

Recommendation 2: do not delete the view with calibration

A hall used as a view may be 1000 x 500 m, with georeferencing (anchor, rotation, scale) and an orthophoto of the plot, and the buildings are areas inside the view. During a test, moving the buildings into separate views deleted the only view with calibration. The editor showed a message about missing georeferencing and the orthophoto disappeared.

Recommendation: before every structure change, make a list of views with calibration and block their deletion. Calibration is the only source for converting local metres to geographic coordinates, so losing it invalidates the whole map.

Recommendation 3: one source of truth for conversions

Converting local metres to geographic coordinates must have one source of truth, and the migration script must be a 1:1 port of this function, with the grid convergence correction for the PUWG 1992 system. Two implementations always end up diverging.

Verification of the transformation on 64 control points gave a maximum error of 0.01 m after converting the outlines back. Every plant should run such a test: convert the points forward and back and measure the largest deviation.

Recommendations 4-6: closing gaps over time

Recommendation 4: assign an owner and a deadline to each gap. A list of objects without position with no owner does not shrink. Recommendation 5: record the position during the first job at the object, when someone is physically there anyway. Recommendation 6: report the number of objects in the Plant site area as an indicator of map maturity, falling over time.

This way the map grows from things that are certain to things that are less certain, not the other way round.

Example calculation

Example of the pace of closing gaps

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Objects without position at the start90 pcs
Objects without position after 4 quarters10 pcs

Result: A decrease of 80 objects, about 89%.

Note: Example calculation; the figures are assumptions for your own planning.

Checklist

Video

Frequently asked questions

Is an object in the Plant site area visible on the map?

No. It has no geometry or point, so it does not appear on the map until a position is assigned, but it remains available for selection in the register.

Why not put them all in the middle of the hall?

Because a pin suggests knowledge that does not exist. The person accepting a permit could assess the risk based on a false position.

What works as a test of coordinate conversion?

Converting a set of control points forward and back and measuring the largest deviation. In the test described, it was 0.01 m across 64 points.

Do you have a register with position gaps?

We will show how to move such a register onto the map safely and how to close the gaps without false pins.

Let's talk