InnerWeb
Skip to main content

NFC, BLE or QR on the phone: which channel to choose for the gate, turnstile and training

The IT department plans to buy mobile identifiers from an access control vendor and must assign a phone channel to three places: the gate, the turnstile and training. Below are six recommendations on how to split NFC, BLE and QR so that you do not overpay or replace readers without need.

13 mm
minimum printed size of the QR code
Source: InnerWeb function documentation

Request stage: what really has to be decided

At the stage of the tender it is easy to list all three channels as requirements, because they sound modern. Each of them, however, has a different cost and a different place in the plant. Instead of asking the vendor 'does it support NFC, BLE and QR', ask which channel supports which passage and what infrastructure on the plant side it assumes.

InnerWeb is a software producer, not a maker of readers or cards. The KD vendor is responsible for the NFC and BLE readers at the turnstile and doors, while InnerWeb receives identifier punch events from the client's KD system and links them with qualifications, permits, attendance and time records.

Recommendation 1: QR at the gate for guests and contractors

A QR code is the right channel for people who enter rarely and whom the plant does not want to register in the KD vendor's system. The code opens in the browser, needs no app and no phone pairing, and security reads it with an HID scanner, a USB-COM scanner through the browser, or the camera in the panel.

The same code serves the gate, the invitation e-mail, field inspection and training login, so you do not need four separate identifiers.

Recommendations 2-3: NFC and BLE at the turnstile and doors

Second recommendation: keep NFC for passages where speed and an unambiguous tap gesture matter, that is for the turnstile of permanent staff. This is the KD vendor's channel, requiring compatible readers and credential management on its side. InnerWeb does not sell readers or cards and does not replace them.

Third: consider BLE where the phone is to open a passage from a distance, for example in vehicle traffic or at a barrier, but ask the vendor whether the plant's readers support it. With existing NFC readers, buying BLE often means replacing hardware, not just software.

Recommendations 4-5: training and code size

Fourth: for training on a tablet choose a QR code, because a scan does not log the person in by itself. It only shows the first name, last name and company of the owner, and training starts after confirming with the button 'Is this you?'. Identifying the string follows one rule on the server side, shared with the gate, so the tablet's browser does not parse it.

Fifth: watch the print parameters if the code also goes onto paper. The default label size is 86 x 54 mm, and the code is not printed smaller than 13 mm. This protects against choosing a format too small for scanners, which read it slowly or not at all.

  • Gate for guests and contractors: QR.
  • Turnstile for permanent staff: NFC on the KD vendor's side.
  • Vehicle passage: BLE, if the readers support it.
  • Training on a tablet: QR with identity confirmation.
  • Backup label: 86 x 54 mm, code at least 13 mm.

Recommendation 6: one data layer above the channels

The sixth recommendation is the most important from the IT point of view: do not tie the plant's policy to a channel. A code, an NFC tap and a BLE signal are three ways of expressing the same fact: a person with certain permissions is at the passage. If they all arrive as events in one layer, changing the channel in a year does not mean rebuilding the rules.

InnerWeb works as an independent system supplementing the client's existing systems (KD, time and attendance, HR, ERP) and does not require GPS for location. In the tender it is therefore worth writing the requirement: the KD vendor provides punch events in an agreed format, and does not only keep them in its own panel.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Is QR enough without NFC?

For guests, contractors and training, yes. The turnstile for permanent staff often stays with cards or with the KD vendor's NFC.

Who supplies the NFC and BLE readers?

The plant's KD vendor. InnerWeb does not make readers and does not replace them.

Can we scan from the phone camera?

A code from an HID scanner, a USB-COM scanner and the camera goes to the same recognition rule on the server side.

Sources

Let us review the tender together with IT

We will help you write the requirements for punch events and the split of channels, without replacing readers. Let's schedule a short call.

Let's talk