Where security loses time in a manual check
In a manual check the security officer performs several steps for each person: asks for a document, looks for the surname on a list or in a spreadsheet, compares the training expiry date, decides and records the entry. Each step is short, but their sum across hundreds of entries a day amounts to hours of work a week. In addition, the queue at the gate grows at shift changes.
When a card punch from the AC system reaches InnerWeb and a scan in the security panel returns the verdict, most of these steps disappear. The contractor permit, qualifications and training are linked to the person's account, so the card number is the key to checking valid OHS training before the gate lets the person through.
What the verdict automates and what stays with people
After a scan of an RFID card or QR badge the security panel returns a verdict made of valid training, qualifications for hazardous work, a permit in progress and an active account. The scan itself records the entry, so a separate entry in the register is not needed.
People remain responsible for exceptional situations: a negative result, a discrepancy between accounts, a visitor without a card. When the same person has two active accounts, the system transfers the training result to the account with the entry card, so that the gate does not report false missing training. The number of such exceptions is usually small compared with the traffic, but it requires discipline in the data.
Training check hours a week (example)
Card traffic as the basis of the calculation
The volume of card traffic at a plant with many staffing agencies may exceed 2,000 punches per working day. At this scale a manual check of training stops being feasible for everyone, so in practice it is done on a sample. The automatic verdict covers every punch, which changes the quality of the control, not only its cost.
In the calculation we assume a deliberately smaller number, so that the result is not overstated. Each plant should use its own traffic from the AC system data for recent weeks.
Example calculation: hours a week
Assumptions of the example: 400 entries a day subject to a training check, 5 working days a week, 40 seconds of manual checking per person, 3 seconds for the scan and reading the verdict, and 8 percent of entries requiring human intervention, with 90 seconds per intervention. The time values are assumptions to be replaced by measurement at the plant.
Calculation
Manual: 400 x 5 x 40 s = 80,000 s, that is approx. 22.2 hours a week. Automatic: 400 x 5 x 3 s = 6,000 s, plus 8 percent of 2,000 entries, that is 160 interventions of 90 s each = 14,400 s. Total 20,400 s, that is approx. 5.7 hours a week. Saving: approx. 16.5 hours a week, that is approx. 74 percent of the checking time.
How to check the result at your plant
Measure the time of a manual check on a dozen or so people at different times of the shift. Take from the AC system the number of punches for recent weeks. After the integration starts, compare the number of interventions with the 8 percent assumption: if it is higher, the cause is often inconsistent spelling of company names or a missing reader place template. The freed time is worth using for patrols and visitor service, not for reducing the checks, because the check now covers every person.
Training check time: manual versus after a card punch
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Entries subject to a check per day | 400 people |
| Working days | 5 days/week |
| Manual check of one person | 40 s |
| Scan and reading of the verdict | 3 s |
| Share of human interventions | 8 % |
| Time of one intervention | 90 s |
Result: Manual approx. 22.2 h a week, automatic approx. 5.7 h a week; saving approx. 16.5 h a week.
Note: Example calculation; the time values are assumptions which the plant should replace with its own measurement.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Where does the saving come from?
From replacing manual searching and comparing of dates with a single scan that returns the verdict and records the entry. People handle only the exceptions.
Are 400 entries a day the plant's data?
No. It is an assumption of the example. A plant with many agencies may have over 2,000 punches per working day, so the plant's own figure should be taken from the AC system data.
Does the saving mean less security?
No. The freed time can be used for patrols and visitor service, and the check now covers every person, not only a sample.
Let's calculate it for your traffic
We will put the number of punches from your AC system into the calculation and show the result. Book a call with the InnerWeb team.
Let's talk