InnerWeb
Skip to main content

How many beacons are needed for a map position? FAQ for the security manager

A worker's position on the plant map is built from the signals of many beacons, not from the single strongest one. A 3D position requires readings from at least 5 beacons, and the signal strength is averaged over up to the last 4 readings. Below are the answers to the questions a security manager asks before placing beacons in the hall and on the plant roads.

5
minimum number of beacons for a 3D position
Source: card
4
last readings averaged for the signal strength
Source: card
100 to 200 m2
building area per 1 beacon
Source: card

How a worker's position is built

A worker's position on the map is built from the signals of many beacons, averaged on the map, and works without GPS. The device carried by the worker receives the signals of the industrial beacons, the system converts the signal strength into an approximate distance, and determines the place where these distances agree best.

For the security manager this has one important consequence: the quality of the position depends on the number and layout of the beacons, not on the range of a single device. A denser and more evenly spread network gives a more stable position than a few beacons with strong signals.

The system is an independent supplement to the plant's existing systems. It does not need satellite coverage, so it works the same way in the hall, under a canopy and between buildings.

How many signals are needed for a 3D position

A 3D position requires readings from at least 5 beacons and is determined by an evolutionary algorithm. The algorithm searches for the location that best explains all measured signal strengths at once, instead of taking only one of them into account.

A simpler mode indicates the nearest location from the signal. It is less demanding, but it does not give a continuous position: it shows a named place, not a point on the map. This is enough to answer in which room the worker is, but not to track the route they take.

The practical conclusion: when planning the layout, check whether at every spot where a 3D position should be reliable, the device can receive at least 5 beacons at the same time. Spots with fewer signals will be served by the simpler mode.

  • 3D position: at least 5 beacons, evolutionary algorithm.
  • Simpler mode: nearest location from the signal.
  • Check the layout against the number of visible beacons at each point, not only against the density on the plan.

Number of beacons in a building at two densities

Number of beacons in a building at two densitiesBar chart: number of beacons for 500, 1,000 and 2,000 m2 at a density of 1 per 200 m2 and 1 per 100 m2.05101520beacons1 per 200 m2 (500 m2): 2.5 beacons2.51 per 100 m2 (500 m2): 5 beacons5500 m21 per 200 m2 (1,000 m2): 5 beacons51 per 100 m2 (1,000 m2): 10 beacons101,000 m21 per 200 m2 (2,000 m2): 10 beacons101 per 100 m2 (2,000 m2): 20 beacons202,000 m2
  • 1 per 200 m2
  • 1 per 100 m2
Source: Example calculation: area divided by 200 m2 and by 100 m2 per beacon (density range from the card)

How many readings are averaged and why

The signal strength is normalised and averaged over up to the last 4 readings. A radio signal in a hall fluctuates: it reflects off metal structures, and it is damped by the human body and by machine movement. A single reading may therefore indicate a distance that is off by several metres.

Averaging smooths out these fluctuations. The price is a short delay: the position reacts after a few readings, not after the first one. For a worker walking at normal speed this is acceptable, and for the dispatcher it means a map without jumping markers.

That is why a single change in the signal, for example a beacon briefly blocked, does not move the worker to the other end of the hall.

Why the strongest beacon alone is not enough

The strongest signal does not always come from the nearest beacon. A metal partition, a shelving unit or the worker's own body attenuates the signal from a close beacon, while a more distant beacon, visible in a straight line, may give a stronger reading. Choosing a single beacon can therefore be misleading.

For this reason the system combines the signals of many beacons and averages them. A single wrong reading has less influence on the result when it is accompanied by four others.

It is also worth knowing that the quality of the position depends on the data in the database. Two physical beacons with an identical major:minor pair are recognised as one, and part of the detections land in the wrong place. The best network geometry will not help if the identifiers are not unique.

How many beacons in the hall and on the road

A plant road requires beacons roughly every 100 m, and inside a building 1 beacon per 100 to 200 m2. At such a density, at a typical point of a building the device sees several beacons at the same time, which meets the requirement of 5 signals for a 3D position.

Worked example: for 1,000 m2 of building this gives from 5 beacons at a density of 1 per 200 m2 up to 10 at a density of 1 per 100 m2. These figures match the minimum of 5 signals, but remember that the device does not see all beacons in the whole building at the same time, so in an open hall and where there are obstacles a higher density is used.

The full calculation for a 5,000 m2 hall is in a separate guide. Here remember the rule: the more important the accuracy in a given place, the closer the density gets to 1 per 100 m2.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Is GPS needed for location?

No. The position is built from the signals of many beacons, averaged on the map, and works without GPS, also inside halls and between buildings.

What happens when a device sees fewer than 5 beacons?

A 3D position requires readings from at least 5 beacons. With fewer, the system uses the simpler mode, which indicates the nearest location from the signal.

Why doesn't the position on the map jump with every reading?

The signal strength is normalised and averaged over up to the last 4 readings, so a single fluctuation of the signal does not move the marker.

Is it enough to install one stronger beacon instead of several weaker ones?

No. The position depends on the set of signals from many beacons. A denser network gives a more stable result than a single high-power device.

Plan the placement of beacons

Book a conversation: we will go through the plant layout with you and point out the places where a 3D position requires a higher density.

Let's talk