InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Cost of manual attendance correction on site

The evacuation coordinator needs a list of people on site that is accurate at every moment, not only after the morning review. We show how much time it costs to clean the list by hand after forgotten exits, and what automatic checkout after 12 hours changes.

12 h
threshold for automatic checkout
Source: karta
approx. 5 h
monthly time of manual corrections in the sample calculation
Source: kalkulacja przykladowa

Where an outdated list of people on site comes from

A guest or contractor enters through the gate and scans the code, but at the exit forgets the second scan or leaves by another route. The register still shows them as present. If nobody corrects it, the list on site grows day by day with people who left the site long ago.

For the evacuation coordinator this is a data quality problem. A list that cannot be trusted forces extra checks at the assembly point, which lengthens the time needed to account for people in a situation where every minute counts.

How automatic checkout after 12 hours works

A person remaining on site for more than 12 hours is checked out automatically. The task runs every 3 hours, that is 8 times a day, and the entry is marked as closed automatically. Thanks to this marking, the register shows that the exit did not come from a scan but from a system rule.

A blocked entry attempt is a separate case: it goes into the register as a refusal entry, but it does not count as presence on site or on the evacuation list. The list therefore does not swell with people who were turned away at the gate.

Monthly time of manual attendance corrections

Monthly time of manual attendance correctionsBefore and after chart: 5.3 hours manually, 1.1 hours with automatic checkout.0246hoursManual only: 5.3 hours5.3 hoursManual onlyWith automatic checkout: 1.1 hours1.1 hoursWith automatic checkout
Source: Sample calculation: 3.6 entries a day, 4 minutes per entry, 22 days; after automation we assume 20% of entries still need manual correction

Sample calculation of the cost of manual correction

The assumptions below are samples and can be replaced with your own data from the site register. We assume a site where 120 external persons enter every day, and 3% of them do not register their exit. This gives about 3.6 forgotten exits per day.

Manually correcting one entry takes the coordinator or porter about 4 minutes: finding the person, checking whether they actually left, adding the exit and noting it. At 3.6 entries a day this is about 14 minutes a day, and over 22 working days in a month about 5 hours of work.

At a sample labour rate of PLN 70 per hour, this amounts to about PLN 350 a month, or about PLN 4,200 a year for one site. The sum is not dramatic. The main benefit of automation is not saving hours, but a reliable list at the moment of an event.

  • External persons per day: 120
  • Share of forgotten exits: 3%
  • Time for manual correction of one entry: 4 minutes
  • Working days per month: 22
  • Labour cost per hour: PLN 70

What remains for manual correction after automation

Automatic checkout does not remove forgotten exits during the first 12 hours. For that time the person stays on the list, which for the evacuation coordinator is a safer assumption than presuming they have left. The rule closes only the entries that exceeded the threshold.

With eight-hour shifts and short visits this means that the entry of a forgotten exit from a morning visit disappears in the afternoon of the next task window. Some manual corrections still remain, but they are exceptions rather than a daily routine.

Group training: an exception that is not a forgotten exit

After passing a group training at the registration point, another scan within 13 minutes is treated as confirmation of presence, not as an exit. After 13 minutes the normal rule applies: entry and exit. Without this rule, a group brought in for training would be recorded as having left before they had even entered the site.

For the cost calculation this means fewer false corrections: some scans that would look like errors are recognised as confirmation of presence and need no human work.

Example calculation

Annual cost of manual attendance correction

Assumptions
ParameterValue
External persons per day120 persons
Share of forgotten exits3 %
Time for correcting one entry4 min
Working days per month22 days
Labour cost per hour70 PLN
Entries still needing manual correction after automation20 %

Result: Manually: about 5.3 hours a month, about PLN 370 a month. With automation: about 1.1 hours. Difference about 4.2 hours a month.

Note: Sample calculation based on the assumptions in the table; replace them with your own site register data.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Can a person left on the list be checked out too early?

No. The rule applies to people staying longer than 12 hours, and the task runs every 3 hours.

How do you tell an exit from a scan apart from an automatic one?

An entry checked out automatically is marked as closed automatically, so an audit sees the difference.

Does a refused entry lengthen the evacuation list?

No. A refusal entry goes into the register, but it does not count as presence on site or on the evacuation list.

Check your list of people on site

We will analyse the entry and exit register with you and show how many manual corrections can be eliminated.

Let's talk