InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Combined patrol audit instead of single findings: what it costs

After a hall patrol the inspector has a dozen or so remarks that must be written down, organised and passed to the manager. Below is a sample calculation of how long it takes to compile findings by hand versus a combined audit with a PDF summary, and what else is gained beyond the hours.

57 min
saving per patrol (assumption 72 min versus 15 min)
Source: sample calculation
45,6 h
a year in one hall with 48 patrols
Source: sample calculation

What a patrol looks like without an audit

Without a combined audit, the remarks from a patrol reach the manager in several forms: in a notebook, in messages, in separate findings or on a paper list. After the patrol the inspector rewrites them into one summary, adds the hall and date, attaches photos and sends it.

This stage takes more time than the patrol itself, and its quality depends on discipline. Remarks get lost, summaries are produced several days later, and the hall manager has no single place to see what still needs doing.

What the combined audit changes

Findings raised during one patrol are grouped into an audit with a name, date, hall and auditor. The inspector does not rewrite anything after the patrol, because the findings are created during it and become audit items themselves.

Audit progress is the number of findings resolved and rejected, divided by all findings, for example 7/10, and the summary is available as a PDF. The manager has one summary that updates itself as findings are closed.

Time after a patrol: manual summary versus audit

Time after a patrol: manual summary versus auditComparison: 72 minutes of manual compiling versus 15 minutes with a combined audit per patrol020406080minutes per patrolManual findings: Time after the patrol: 72 minutes per patrol72Manual findingsCombined audit: Time after the patrol: 15 minutes per patrol15Combined audit
Source: Sample calculation based on the assumptions in the Calculation section

Sample calculation with stated assumptions

The figures below are sample assumptions. A plant should substitute its own number of patrols, findings per patrol and working time.

We assume 4 patrols a month in one hall, which is 48 a year, and 12 findings per patrol. A manual summary takes on average 6 minutes per finding (writing down, describing the location, a photo, handover), which is 72 minutes per patrol. With the combined audit we assume 15 minutes per patrol: reviewing the list, adding the name and downloading the PDF. The saving is 57 minutes per patrol, which is 2,736 minutes a year, about 45.6 hours. At a cost of 90 PLN per hour, this gives roughly 4,100 PLN a year for one hall.

Scale: several halls and several inspectors

The saving grows linearly with the number of halls. With the same assumptions, five halls amount to about 228 hours a year, which is more than five weeks of one full-time post. For the OHS department this is time that can go into patrols themselves, training and root cause analysis.

The real scale, however, also comes from quality. The combined audit reduces the number of remarks lost along the way and shortens the time from finding to handover to the manager, because the findings reach them at once.

Benefits beyond hours

The audit leaves a trail for an external audit: from finding the defect, through assignment, to resolution or rejection. The audit status is calculated on reading: Open, In progress, Completed, so it requires no manual updates.

A finding belongs to at most one audit at a time. This limits double counting and disputes over who is handling the matter. The manager sees the progress of their own hall, and the inspector sees which remarks from the previous patrol are still waiting.

Link with the findings report

Audit data can be compared with the findings report, which shows the number of findings created and closed, the median time to response and resolution, and tables by category, status, location and type. The scheduled report answers the question of how quickly the plant closes remarks, while the audit answers the question of what was found during a specific patrol.

This combination is useful at management meetings: the audit shows the state of a hall, the report shows the trend over time.

Example calculation

Sample calculation: combined patrol audit

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Patrols in one hall48 a year (4 a month)
Findings per patrol12 findings
Manual compiling of one finding6 minutes
Time after the patrol with an audit15 minutes
Cost of an hour of work90 PLN

Result: Manual: 72 min per patrol, with the audit 15 min. Saving 57 min per patrol, 45.6 h a year and roughly 4,100 PLN in one hall.

Note: Sample calculation based on the assumptions above; the results for a specific plant depend on the number of halls, patrols and the cost of labour. Platform pricing is individual.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Does the audit replace the patrol?

No. The inspector carries out the patrol, and the audit organises its results and makes sure remarks are not lost.

Can the PDF from the audit be attached to the protocol?

Yes. The audit summary is available as a PDF, suitable for the protocol and for the OHS archive.

Can the same findings end up in two audits?

No. A finding belongs to at most one audit at a time.

Calculate the audit for your halls

Together we will put the number of halls, patrols and findings into the calculation. Book a call with InnerWeb.

Let's talk