Symptom visible to the safety manager
The safety manager at a production plant noticed that the gate check rejected a person with a message about a missing valid training record, although the person said they had completed the training the previous day on a tablet in the training room. The report looked like a security error or a human one, but nobody could say where the training had been recorded.
The symptom repeated for several people within one week. This is a typical sign that the cause lies in the process, not in isolated mistakes: the same gap reappears each time the same conditions coincide.
How the badge scan works in training
The same QR code on the badge serves four purposes: the gate check, the e-mail invitation, the check on the floor and the training login on a tablet. A phone or tablet camera scans the code and opens an address with the badge token, with no app to install, and the token is passed to the training screen as an entry parameter.
However, the scan does not log the person in by itself. The screen shows the first name, last name and company of the code owner, and the training starts only after a person confirms it, because a badge can lie on a table or end up with another person.
Diagnosis: where the result was recorded
The diagnosis began by reconstructing the path: scan, confirmation screen, training, saving the result, gate check. At each step the team checked which account the result was going to, instead of guessing from the gate message.
It turned out that the training screen could be opened in two modes: with the badge token and without it. In the mode without a token, the user selects a company and types a login by hand, and with a typo or a similar login the training is saved to someone else's account. The gate checks the account of the badge owner, so it saw no training.
- The gate check reads the account assigned to the badge.
- Training saved after a manual login entry goes to the entered account, not to the badge account.
- Both paths look the same to the user, so the error was invisible.
Fix: a screen opened from a badge does not show the login form
The fix concerned how the screen behaves when it is opened from a badge. In that case the company selection and login form is not displayed at all, even if the code was not recognized. Instead, a message and a button to scan again appear.
The form was removed because an unrecognized code had previously sent the user back to the manual form, which was the path that allowed saving to the wrong account. Now the only way out of a badge is a new scan or help from the gate officer, and a parameter passed in the address decides the mode of the screen.
Why a person still confirms
Confirmation of the first name, last name and company was kept, because a scan proves possession of the code, not identity. A badge can lie on a table or end up with another person, so the screen shows whose training it is before the material starts.
Effect and verification
After the change the same scenario was repeated: badge scan, training, gate check. The result was saved to the badge owner's account and the gate saw it. The case of an unknown code was also checked: the screen showed a message and a button to scan again, with no login form.
For the safety manager the most important change is that the training register no longer depends on the attentiveness of the person entering the login. One rule on the screen replaced a dozen individual mistakes that could not be reproduced.
Conclusions for plants that use QR codes in training
If the gate and the training read the account from different sources, sooner or later you will see training on the wrong account. It is worth checking three things: whether the training screen opened from a badge offers a manual path, whether it confirms the owner of the code, and whether the gate check reads the same account to which the result is saved.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Does a badge scan log the person into training automatically?
No. The screen shows the first name, last name and company of the code owner, and training starts only after a person confirms it.
What happens when the code is not recognized?
The screen opened from the badge shows a message and a button to scan again, and the company and login form is not displayed.
How can we check whether we have the same problem?
Compare the account to which the training result is saved with the account read by the gate check, for a person entering through the manual path and through a scan.
Do you suspect training saved to the wrong accounts?
Let's talk about an audit of the path from the scan to the gate check on your installation.
Let's talk