The situation: a night-time power failure in one section
The case described is generic, built from typical events in the sector, with no reference to a specific entity. The steelworks operates continuously, with four shift crews. It employs several hundred of its own people and a dozen or so external companies, which carry out overhaul work at night on neighbouring lines.
Just after two in the morning the switchgear feeding one of the sections trips: a medium-voltage circuit breaker has failed. The section accounts for about 40% of the steelworks' output. Cooling pumps switch to backup power only partly, and the section's control system loses communication with the controllers. Alarms light up in the control room, and the operator sees that some process parameters are stale.
The problem: two risks at once, technological and human
The first risk is technological. Without cooling and without oversight of parameters, the line has to be taken out in a controlled way, not simply shut down. An uncontrolled stop means a risk of damage to the lining, scrap and a longer restart.
The second risk is human and usually gets less attention in plans. At the moment of the failure people are working in the section: operators, but also external contractors under permits. Some of them are in zones where work is not allowed without lighting and ventilation. In a few minutes the incident manager must answer three questions: who is on site, who is in the affected section, and which work has to be stopped immediately.
In plants that issue work permits, a common problem is their precision. A permit names a building or a hall, not a specific machine or section. On a normal day that is an inconvenience. In a failure it means that the list of work in progress does not answer the question of who is near the powered switchgear.
Cost of a section power failure: without and with a plan (sample calculation)
- Without a plan (10 h)
- With a plan (3 h)
The solution: an emergency plan with a presence list and work in progress
The steelworks continuity plan for the "loss of power to a section" scenario sets out a sequence of actions counted in minutes. The activation threshold is loss of power to the section for more than 5 minutes or no communication with controllers for more than 10 minutes. It is declared by the shift supervisor, whose deputy is the power dispatcher.
In the first 15 minutes four parallel tasks are carried out. The operator switches critical circuits to backup power and starts the manual line shutdown procedure. The power dispatcher locates the fault and decides whether switching to another supply is possible. The health and safety coordinator collects the on-site personnel list and the list of work in progress. The communications coordinator issues a message over radio and telephone.
Presence list: who is on site
To establish who is physically in the plant, the plan uses an evacuation list generated from QR scans at the gate. The list refreshes every 13 seconds and divides people into six groups: guests, couriers, suppliers, plant employees, external companies (with a tab per company) and uncertain. Where the list has to compromise, it errs towards showing too many people, not too few. A printout, one page per group, goes to the coordinators at the assembly point.
Work in progress: which to stop
The permit list shows who is doing the work, in what phase and in which area. A permit is an electronic document that goes through preparation, main work and closure phases, and the plant has a live view of who is working where. The coordinator can therefore select the permits for the unpowered section and pass them on to be suspended. When needed, suspending work is a function of the system, not a phone call to each foreman separately.
There is one condition: precision. If permits name a specific machine or section, the list of work in progress answers the question raised by the failure. If they name only the hall, the coordinator will call every contractor in the hall. That is why improving the plant's location structure is part of preparing for continuity, not an add-on.
Sample calculation: event cost with and without a plan
The sample calculation is not based on any customer's data. Assumptions: steelworks output value PLN 1,200,000 per day, that is PLN 50,000 per hour. The section accounts for 40% of output, that is PLN 20,000 per hour. Contribution margin 30%, so the lost margin is PLN 6,000 for each hour of section downtime.
Without a plan, downtime lasts 10 hours: establishing who is in the section takes a long time, the line shutdown is improvised, and the restart is slower. Lost margin is PLN 60,000, the cost of an uncontrolled stop and restart PLN 60,000, and manual work by a team of 10 people at PLN 70 per hour for 10 hours is PLN 7,000. Total PLN 127,000.
With a plan, downtime lasts 3 hours. Lost margin is PLN 18,000, the cost of a controlled shutdown and restart PLN 15,000, manual work PLN 2,100. Total PLN 35,100. The difference on a single event is about PLN 91,900.
The result and conclusions for the plant director
The case shows that the cost of a failure is decided by the minutes spent on making a decision and establishing who is in the affected place. Backup power and manual mode are needed, but without a presence list and control of work in progress the coordinator is acting blind. A list without a procedure changes nothing either: someone must have the right to use it.
The plan should be exercised in a night-time variant, when fewer people are on site and contractors work without direct supervision. During the exercise, measure the time from declaring the plan to producing the list of people in the section. The target is a few minutes, not a quarter of an hour.
For an entity covered by the Polish National Cybersecurity System Act (KSC), such documentation provides audit evidence for business continuity: the plan, the exercise record and the recorded times. The CER approach also requires it, as it links continuity with physical protection and the safety of people working for the entity.
Cost of a power failure in one steelworks section
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Steelworks output value | 1,200,000 PLN per day |
| Section share of output | 40 % |
| Contribution margin | 30 % |
| Downtime without a plan | 10 hours |
| Downtime with a plan | 3 hours |
| Manual work by the team | 10 people at PLN 70/h PLN |
Result: About PLN 127,000 without a plan, about PLN 35,100 with a plan, a difference of about PLN 91,900 per event.
Note: Sample calculation: it excludes contractual penalties, equipment damage and loss of customers. Substitute your own values from the business impact analysis.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Is an evacuation list enough to establish who is in the section?
No. It shows who is on the plant site. To establish presence in the section you need location tracking or precise permits that name the machine. The two sources complement each other in the plan.
Who should declare plan activation at night?
The shift supervisor, with a deputy named for each shift. The activation threshold should be measurable so that the decision needs no consultation.
How can this scenario be exercised without stopping the line?
With a tabletop exercise simulating loss of power, measuring the time to declare the plan, obtain the personnel list and suspend work. Technical elements are tested in service windows.
Sources
Let us exercise a failure in your plant
Let us talk about how the on-site personnel list and permits that name the machine support an emergency plan. We will show what runs on the customer's server.
Let's talk