Where the split between upper-tier and lower-tier comes from
Directive 2012/18/EU on the control of major-accident hazards involving dangerous substances, known as Seveso III, divides establishments into two categories according to the quantities of substances that may be present on site. In Polish law the directive is implemented by the part of the Environmental Protection Law (Prawo ochrony środowiska) devoted to preventing major accidents, and the ZDR and ZZR classification results from exceeding thresholds set in implementing regulations based on Annex I of the directive.
The words "may be present" matter. Classification depends not on the average stock level but on the largest quantity that can be on site at any time, including intermediate installations, process pipelines and temporary storage. A site that periodically receives a larger raw material delivery should count the peak quantity, not the annual average.
Quantity criteria: thresholds and the summation rule
Annex I of the directive has two parts. Part 1 groups substances by hazard category (toxic, oxidising, explosive, flammable, hazardous to the environment), and part 2 names specific substances, for example chlorine, anhydrous ammonia, hydrogen, liquefied gas or petroleum products. Each entry has two values in tonnes: the lower threshold defines a lower-tier site and the higher threshold defines an upper-tier site.
Example values from part 2 of Annex I (lower threshold / higher threshold): chlorine 10 t / 25 t, anhydrous ammonia 50 t / 200 t, liquefied gas (LPG) 50 t / 200 t, hydrogen 5 t / 50 t, petrol and naphtha 2,500 t / 25,000 t. Always verify the values against the current text of the directive, because the annex is amended from time to time.
When several substances are present on site, none of them needs to exceed a threshold on its own. The summation rule applies: the quantities of individual substances in the same hazard category are divided by their thresholds and the fractions are added up. A sum equal to or greater than one means the threshold for that category is exceeded. The rule means that a site with many "small" stores can be classified more strictly than an assessment of each of them separately would suggest.
- Chlorine: 10 t (lower tier) / 25 t (upper tier)
- Anhydrous ammonia: 50 t (lower tier) / 200 t (upper tier)
- Liquefied gas LPG: 50 t (lower tier) / 200 t (upper tier)
- Hydrogen: 5 t (lower tier) / 50 t (upper tier)
- Petrol and naphtha: 2,500 t (lower tier) / 25,000 t (upper tier)
Lower-tier and upper-tier thresholds for selected substances
- Lower-tier threshold
- Upper-tier threshold
Obligations common to lower-tier and upper-tier sites
An operator whose site qualifies for either category notifies the site to the competent authorities: the provincial commander of the State Fire Service and the provincial environmental protection inspector. The notification contains the operator's details, a description of the activity, a list of dangerous substances with quantities and information about the surroundings. Every significant change, for example a new installation or a change in quantities, requires an update.
The second common obligation is to draw up and implement a major accident prevention policy. This is the document in which the operator sets out the safety policy, the organisation and supervision rules, the roles of responsible persons and the method of identifying hazards. The policy is not a formal exercise: inspectors check whether its provisions are reflected in practice, that is in instructions, training records, permits and inspections.
Additional obligations of upper-tier sites
An upper-tier site is responsible for a fuller set of documents. The most important is the safety report: an analysis of hazards, accident scenarios, prevention and mitigation measures, and a description of the installation and the safety management system. The directive requires the report to be reviewed at least every five years and after every change that significantly affects hazards, and also when new technical facts or lessons from accident analysis emerge.
On top of this come a safety management system, an internal emergency plan (the directive requires it to be reviewed at least every three years) and cooperation on the external plan prepared by the authorities. An upper-tier site also has information duties towards the local community: people in the zone of potential impact should know how to behave in an accident.
The scope of plans for lower-tier sites should be confirmed in national regulations and with the competent Fire Service commander, because the details differ from the requirements for upper-tier sites.
Operational evidence that inspectors look for
The directive introduces an inspection plan: at upper-tier sites an on-site inspection takes place at least once a year, at lower-tier sites at least once every three years, unless the authority sets a different period based on a risk assessment. An inspection rarely stops at reading the report. The inspector asks about records: who carried out maintenance work in the last month, whether they had valid initial training, which permit allowed them to do hot work and who approved it.
This is where a digital permit and training system comes in. InnerWeb is software that stores electronic work permits, qualifications and training results of employees, including those of external companies, and records who changed a permit or a training result and when. When a permit is created, the system checks whether the assigned workers hold the required, valid qualifications. This provides evidence for an audit that the provisions of the accident prevention policy are carried out in daily work, but it does not replace the hazard analysis or the decision of the process engineer.
For hot work, the system enforces an observation period after the work ends and records its course, and the list of people on site from the QR gate is ready for evacuation purposes. These are operational evidence items that support meeting the requirements of the report and the plan, provided the site uses them consistently.
Cybersecurity as the third pillar
Chemical and refinery sites are often also subject to the National Cybersecurity System Act (KSC) after the amendment transposing the NIS2 directive, in force since 3 April 2026. For essential entities, fines can reach EUR 10 million or 2% of revenue, and fines in most categories can be imposed from 3 April 2028. For process control and safety systems at Seveso installations, this means linking process hazard analysis with the cyber risk assessment of OT.
In practice: major accident scenarios in the safety report should include cyber causes, and records of physical access and of work permits for control systems should form part of the evidence for both regimes.
Checklist
Video
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between an upper-tier and a lower-tier establishment?
The difference is the size of the stock of dangerous substances. A lower-tier site exceeds the lower thresholds of Annex I to Directive 2012/18/EU, an upper-tier site the higher ones. An upper-tier site additionally needs a safety report and a wider scope of emergency plans.
Can a site change its category?
Yes. A change in substance quantities, the production profile or the installation can move a site up or down. The operator updates the notification and documents, and the authorities verify the new classification.
Does a permit system replace the safety report?
No. A permit and training system provides operational evidence that procedures are carried out. The hazard analysis and the report remain the responsibility of the operator.
Sources
Gather operational evidence in one place
Let's talk about how permits, training and entry records can provide evidence for an audit at your site. Individual quotation.
Let's talk