InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Cost of safety patrols: a paper log versus checkpoints on the map

The cost of a safety patrol is not only the time of the walk itself. It also includes rewriting results, searching for old sheets and the delay between spotting a fault and reporting it. We compare a paper log with map checkpoints using the example of a plant with several halls and a dozen or so patrol routes a month.

-25 min
per patrol route in the example calculation
Source: example calculation
6.7 h
per month with 16 routes
Source: example calculation

What the cost of a paper patrol consists of

A paper patrol has four costs. The first is the patrol itself: the time of the person with the checklist. The second is rewriting: the findings from the sheet are transferred to a spreadsheet or an e-mail so that someone can fix them. The third is searching: when an auditor asks when a given ladder was last inspected, someone goes through the binder. The fourth is delay: a fault found on Monday reaches a report on Tuesday or Wednesday.

None of these costs is large on its own, but together they consume time that could go to removing hazards. In a plant where several patrol routes run at the same time and several people record results, it is especially hard to keep one consistent recording format.

How a patrol with map points works

In the digital approach, patrols are checkpoints on the map, and each has its own checklist. Points are combined into routes per department. A nonconformity entered on the checklist immediately becomes a report, with a location and a photo, so there is no rewriting stage.

Reports from one patrol are grouped into an audit with a name, a date and an auditor. An auditor who asks about the last inspection of a specific place gets the answer from the history of the point, not from a binder.

Periodic reports, covering among other things deliveries, reports and patrols, are generated daily, weekly or monthly and are sent by e-mail as PDF with the client logo, optionally with XLSX. For the health and safety manager this means an end to assembling the monthly summary by hand from sheets.

Time of one patrol route

Time of one patrol routeBefore and after chart: paper 40 minutes of patrol and 30 minutes after it, map 40 minutes of patrol and 5 minutes after it.010203040minPaper (Patrol): 40 min40 minMap points (Patrol): 40 min40 minPatrolPaper (After the patrol): 30 min30 minMap points (After the patrol): 5 min5 minAfter the patrol
  • Paper
  • Map points
Source: Example calculation on the assumptions from the calculation section

Example calculation: several halls, a dozen routes a month

Assume a plant with 4 halls and 16 patrol routes a month. A patrol takes 40 minutes on average. With paper, add 15 minutes of rewriting results after the patrol, 10 minutes to add any reports in the system and 5 minutes to archive the sheet, a total of 30 minutes. With map points, rewriting disappears and about 5 minutes remain to review the result.

Result: paper comes to 70 minutes per route, the map to 45 minutes per route. The difference is 25 minutes per route, which for 16 routes is 400 minutes a month, about 6.7 hours. Multiplying by the hourly rate of your health and safety employee gives the monthly saving; we do not state an amount, because it depends on your costs.

Caveat: this is an example calculation on assumptions that can be changed. If a patrol takes 20 minutes at your plant and rewriting takes 5, the saving will be smaller; if there are 40 routes, it will be larger. The most important change is qualitative: the disappearance of the delay between finding a fault and reporting it.

What this calculation does not include

It does not include the implementation cost: configuring the points, printing labels and training the people who carry out the patrols. Indicative ranges from 2025 to 2026 implementations depend on the number of points and routes, and pricing is individual.

It also does not include benefits that are hard to measure: better visibility of repeated nonconformities in the same place, a shorter time from identifying a hazard to removing it, and the ability to show an auditor the history of a point. These are worth describing in words in the investment justification, without assigning amounts to them.

We suggest a simple test: choose one hall and two routes, run them digitally for a month, and compare the time with the previous month on paper.

Example calculation

Patrol time per month

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Patrol routes per month16 routes
Patrol40 minutes
Activities after the patrol, paper30 minutes
Activities after the patrol, map5 minutes

Result: Paper: 70 minutes per route, map: 45 minutes. Difference 25 minutes per route, 400 minutes a month, about 6.7 hours.

Note: Example calculation. It does not include the implementation cost; insert your own number of routes, times and hourly rate.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Does a nonconformity from the checklist become a report automatically?

Yes. A nonconformity on a point's checklist becomes a report, so findings do not have to be rewritten.

How are patrol results grouped?

Reports from one hall patrol are combined into an audit with a name, a date and an auditor.

Does the monthly report have to be compiled by hand?

No. Periodic reports arrive by e-mail as PDF with the client logo, optionally with XLSX.

Let us compare patrols in your hall

Together we will choose two routes for a trial and prepare a sheet with your times.

Let's talk