InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Location in canteens and smoking areas: how to settle the dispute with unions

The most common point of dispute with trade unions when introducing location tracking is whether the system may operate in canteens, smoking areas and toilets. The scenario below shows how an HR department at a unionised plant prepares wording in an internal act that is defensible legally and workable technically.

14 days
from announcement of the act to launch
Source: Labour Code, Article 22(2) §§ 6-10
3
wording variants for the support areas to compare
Source: example calculation

The situation: an internal act and a dispute over facilities

The scenario describes a concept for a manufacturing plant where trade unions are active and the HR department prepares an internal act on tracking employees in the hall and in the support areas. It is not a description of a finished dispute, but a typical path worth planning before the draft act goes to consultation.

Employee location tracking is a different form of monitoring under Article 22(3) § 4 of the Labour Code, and under § 3 Article 22(2) §§ 6-10 applies to it accordingly. This requires an internal act: work rules, a collective agreement or a notice. In a plant with unions this document becomes the field of negotiation.

The dispute usually starts with one sentence: 'the system covers the whole plant area'. Union representatives ask whether this also includes toilets, changing rooms, the canteen and the smoking area. The answer must be explicit in the act, not implied.

What the law says about toilets, smoking areas and canteens

For video monitoring, Article 22(2) § 2 excludes sanitary rooms, changing rooms, canteens and smoking areas, unless the purpose of monitoring requires otherwise and this does not violate dignity or personal rights. Article 22(3) refers to Article 22(2) only in the scope of §§ 6-10, so § 2 does not apply here. Toilets, smoking areas and canteens may therefore be covered by location tracking, but this requires an explicit entry in the internal act and additional marking.

This distinction is the core of the dispute. For the employer it means the law does not close the road, and for the unions it means that the absence of a statutory ban does not equal the consent of the workforce. The decision is therefore an organisational one, which must be justified by its purpose, not only by a legal provision.

Why permissibility alone is not enough

The minimisation principle in Article 5(1)(c) GDPR requires data to be adequate and limited to the purpose. If the purpose is organising permits for dangerous work in the hall, it is hard to justify the need to know where an employee is in a toilet. Narrowing the scope is therefore good practice, even where the statute does not require it.

Comparison of wording variants: dispute risk and DPIA rating

Comparison of wording variants: dispute risk and DPIA ratingChart comparing three wording variants on the support areas: variant A has the lowest risk, variant C the highest.012345points on a scale of 1-5Variant ADispute risk with unions (Variant A): 1 points on a scale of 1-51Risk in the DPIA assessment (Variant A): 1 points on a scale of 1-51Variant BDispute risk with unions (Variant B): 2 points on a scale of 1-52Risk in the DPIA assessment (Variant B): 2 points on a scale of 1-52Variant CDispute risk with unions (Variant C): 5 points on a scale of 1-55Risk in the DPIA assessment (Variant C): 4 points on a scale of 1-54
  • Dispute risk with unions
  • Risk in the DPIA assessment
Source: Example calculation: the author's qualitative rating on a scale of 1-5 for the scenario, without statistical data

Three wording variants and their effects

In the scenario the HR department prepares three wording variants and compares them from the unions', legal and technical perspectives. Each variant can be reproduced in the system, because the position is calculated from signals of several transmitters placed according to the map, so the reach of location depends on where the transmitters are installed.

  • Variant A, exclusion: toilets, changing rooms, the canteen and the smoking area are outside the location area. No transmitters are installed there, and the act lists the excluded zones. The easiest to accept for the unions.
  • Variant B, exclusion with an evacuation exception: support zones are outside location during normal work, and for the evacuation list and the alarm a separate purpose described in the act applies.
  • Variant C, inclusion: location also covers the support areas, with an explicit statement of purpose, additional marking and justification. Legally possible, but the hardest to negotiate and the highest in the DPIA risk assessment.

Recommendation for the scenario

In the HR scenario the recommendation is variant A with elements of B: support areas outside location, and the SOS alarm described as a separate purpose under Article 207 § 2 of the Labour Code. This setup reduces the risk of dispute and the number of transmitters to install, because in a building one transmitter is installed per 100-200 m2 only where location makes sense.

Marking and deadlines: what must happen before launch

Whatever the variant, the order from Article 22(2) §§ 6-10 applies: the internal act, 14 days from announcement to launch, written information before the employee is admitted to work, and marking of the area no later than the day before launch. In variant C the marking also covers the support rooms.

The unions raise one more element in the talks: a readable map of zones. If the act has a graphic annex with the location areas and the excluded areas marked, the number of questions during consultation falls, because everyone can see the boundary. An isometric map of the hall with the transmitters is a natural material for such an annex.

After the act is announced, the HR department collects confirmations that the information was delivered. A signed employee declaration is not required by statute, but a signed list is a recommended proof for a Labour Inspectorate (PIP) inspection.

Conclusions from the negotiations

The most important conclusion: the dispute over the canteen and smoking area can be turned into a decision on scope, if the act names the zones openly and gives the purpose for each. The second conclusion: narrowing the scope is cheaper than defending a broad scope against the unions and the inspector. The third: written information and marking are elements that cannot be made up after the start.

InnerWeb, as a software producer, does not settle such a dispute, but it lets the outcome be reproduced: the controller sets the location zones and access roles to history according to the act, and changes to data in selected areas leave a trace in the audit log.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Is location tracking in a toilet permissible?

Article 22(2) § 2 does not apply to location tracking, so the statute does not ban it. It does require an explicit entry in the act and additional marking, and the GDPR minimisation principle argues for excluding such places.

Do the unions have to agree to the act?

The internal act may take the form of work rules, a collective agreement or a notice. Consultation requirements depend on the form and the rules in force at the plant, so it is worth settling them with the legal department before publication.

Can the scope be changed after launch?

A change of scope means a change of the act, so the deadlines and the information obligations apply again. It is more sensible to start with a narrow scope.

How is the location area marked?

Marking must be done no later than the day before launch. In the variant with support areas, separate signs are added in those rooms.

Sources

Prepare the location scope for talks with unions

We will show how to reproduce the zones from the act on the hall map and how to set access roles to history.

Let's talk