Starting point
The line was built over a decade ago under Directive 2006/42/EC. The plant wants to raise throughput by more than ten percent, replace controllers with newer ones, add remote service access for suppliers and connect the machines to the production monitoring system. The changes cover both safety-related control systems and the software that manages the work cycle.
The maintenance department assumes that the controller supplier will do its part and the plant will simply accept the result. In earlier upgrades such a split was enough. The technical manager's question is now different: after 20 January 2027, will the plant become the manufacturer of its own line?
The problem: who is the manufacturer after a substantial modification
Under Regulation (EU) 2023/1230, a person who carries out a substantial modification of a machine is treated as its manufacturer. This means a duty to carry out a risk assessment, apply the appropriate conformity assessment procedure and prepare technical documentation. Whether a change is substantial follows from an analysis of its impact on safety: new hazards, changed risk levels, changed safety functions.
In the case described, replacing the safety controllers and adding remote service access come out of the risk assessment as a substantial change. On top of that come the new requirements of Annex III points 1.1.9 and 1.2.1: protection against corruption of control systems, and their safety and reliability. Remote access without account control and a change log directly contradicts the spirit of these points.
Breakdown of the 252 documentation hours for the line
The solution: a five-step path
The plant adopted a plan in which responsibility is split explicitly between the plant, the integrator and the component suppliers. The order of the steps matters, because the result of an earlier step affects the scope of the next.
- An inventory of the 14 machines and an assessment of which changes are substantial and which are ordinary part replacement
- A risk assessment covering hazards from third-party interference and software changes
- Zones and communication channels following the IEC 62443 concept, with remote access separated
- Agreeing with controller suppliers on provisions for resilience, service accounts and updates
- Technical documentation in digital form with a software version log
Remote service access
Supplier access to the controllers was moved to a separate channel with named accounts, time limits and a session log. Shared accounts and default passwords were disabled. The plant required suppliers to prove that the software after the changes is saved with a checksum and a date.
Evidence for acceptance
The acceptance criteria became: a complete set of technical documentation, a description of zones and channels, a software change log and the result of a test of resistance to unauthorised access. These documents support meeting the requirement and provide evidence for an audit, but it is the manufacturer, in this case the plant, that is responsible for the conformity assessment.
The result: an example calculation of documentation time
The team estimated the effort of taking on the manufacturer's role. Assumptions: 14 machines, on average 18 hours of work per machine (inventory, risk assessment, cybersecurity documentation, instructions and testing), an internal rate of PLN 140 per hour. This gives 252 hours and PLN 35,280. It is an example calculation on explicit assumptions, not a measurement.
The largest share of time, 84 hours, goes to the risk assessment including external interference. The smallest, 28 hours, goes to the inventory, but it determines the scope of everything else. Whoever does it a week before acceptance pays later in rework.
Conclusions for other plants
First, the manufacturer's role can be taken on unknowingly. Remote access and new controllers are typical changes that qualify an upgrade as substantial. Second, the risk assessment should be done before the order, not after delivery, because it affects the scope of the supplier's work. Third, a software change log and control of service accounts are evidence the plant will have to show anyway in an NIS2 supply chain audit.
A plant that does not prepare for this risks a halt in line acceptance until the documentation is completed. Such a delay usually costs more than the documentation itself, because it stops commissioning.
Time and cost of documentation after taking on the manufacturer's role
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Number of machines in the upgrade | 14 machines |
| Effort per machine | 18 h |
| Internal rate | 140 PLN/h |
Result: 252 hours and PLN 35,280
Note: Example calculation on generic assumptions; the result depends on machine complexity and the quality of supplier documentation available.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Does every upgrade make the plant a manufacturer?
No. The manufacturer's role follows from a substantial modification, which is assessed through an analysis of impact on safety. Replacing parts with equivalent ones usually does not meet that threshold.
Will the controller supplier take over the manufacturer's responsibility?
The supplier is responsible for its own components. The whole modified machine is the responsibility of whoever carried out the substantial modification, so the split must be written into the contract.
Which points of the regulation concern remote access?
Annex III point 1.1.9 (protection against corruption) and point 1.2.1 (safety and reliability of control systems). Remote access should have account control and a session log.
Sources
Plan the upgrade with evidence from day one
Let's talk about access control for contractors and service staff entering machine zones. Book a conversation with the InnerWeb team.
Let's talk