Why GPS fails in halls, basements and on process units
A GPS receiver needs a view of the sky with several satellites at once. A hall roof, the floors of several levels, thick reinforced-concrete walls and steel structures attenuate the signal so strongly that the position is either not fixed or jumps by tens of metres. On extensive installations, dense pipe racks and tanks add narrow signal canyons.
For occupational safety this is not a minor inconvenience. A person working alone in an engine room, on a tank platform or in a cable basement is exactly the one whose position the dispatcher needs most, and that is where GPS is weakest. In practice, an SOS alarm tells you that something is happening, but not where.
How positioning from BLE beacons works
BLE beacons (iBeacon) are small transmitters that periodically broadcast their identifier. The worker's device, for example a phone or a card, sends nothing to the beacon: it listens. Periodically it sends the platform a list of the transmitters it hears, with the signal strength of each, battery level and status. This is how the worker location function based on BLE beacons works: the position results from data sent by the device, not from satellites.
The platform knows the coordinates of every beacon on the plant plan, so from the list of heard identifiers it can calculate where the device carrier is. The data feeds the view of people on site, automatic assignment to permits and safety signals. It works without GPS, so the same principle applies on the road, in a hall and in a basement.
Area served by 1 beacon
An averaged position, not "the strongest wins"
The most common mistake in thinking about BLE is: the device is where it hears the strongest beacon. That method is cheap but causes position jumps, because signal strength depends on device orientation, the wearer's body, metal walls and reflections. It is enough for a worker to turn their back to the nearest beacon and another one becomes the "winner".
In the InnerWeb system the position is determined from the signals of many beacons at once and averaged on the map. The receiver hears several beacons, each with its own signal strength, and the result is a compromise between them. A single disturbance in one signal is diluted among the others. When assessing vendors, it is worth demanding an explicit description of the averaging algorithm and proof of operation without GPS in real terrain.
Beacon density: how many and where
Deployment experience from a project for a petrochemical plant yields two placement rules. On plant roads beacons are placed about every 100 m, because what matters there is the movement of vehicles and pedestrians in open space. Inside buildings the rule is 1 beacon per 100–200 m2, so that the position is enough to recognise the room and, in multi-storey buildings, the floor.
Beacons are placed more densely indoors than on roads for one reason: walls and ceilings attenuate the signal, so the floor is decided by the beacon heard in a given vertical. That is why beacons are mounted on each level separately, rather than counting the total area of the whole building.
- Roads and yards: about 100 m spacing along the route
- Buildings: 1 beacon per 100–200 m2 of each floor
- Critical zones (stairwells, entrances): locally denser, after a site audit
What to prepare before deployment
The first step is a plant plan with buildings and floors. The plant structure is drawn in the map editor, and the online map has an indoor mode with floor selection, so the dispatcher sees not only the building but also the floor where the worker is. The map is built for each facility separately, so a ready-made plant map should not be assumed without deployment work.
The second step is to establish what devices workers already carry. Often a company phone with the app is enough, without replacing hardware. Operation of the app on a specific phone model must, however, be confirmed on the customer's device. The third step is the decision on where the system runs: a plant server or the cloud is chosen by the plant, and the data stays with the customer.
Limitations we should be honest about
BLE positioning is not a geodetic measurement. In the simulation for a petrochemical plant described in the card, with beacons every 100 m, the average position deviation was 15 m and the maximum 39 m. These are simulation values, not a guarantee for every site. Accuracy depends on beacon density, materials and floor height, which is why calibration is performed after installation.
Accuracy in metres should not be quoted without a source. The only public figure from the InnerWeb presentation is a city project with 11,000 beacons, where accuracy was below 1.5 m across 95 facilities. It cannot be transferred to every plant. A reliable offer includes a measurement on the customer's site, not one number for everyone.
How this relates to audits and safety obligations
Knowing where workers are supports meeting occupational safety and evacuation requirements, and the position history provides audit evidence: who was in the zone, when and for how long. The system does not replace evacuation procedures, because the route and assembly point are not its function. It does show the list of people and their last known position, which for the incident commander can be the most valuable information in the first minutes.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Does indoor positioning require GPS?
No. The position results from the signals of BLE beacons heard by the worker's device, so it works in halls, basements and on installations without a view of the sky.
Does the strongest beacon decide the position?
No. The position is determined from the signals of many beacons at once and averaged on the map, which limits jumps caused by reflections and device orientation.
How many beacons does a building need?
The starting point is 1 beacon per 100–200 m2, separately for each floor. The final number is set by a site audit.
How accurate is the positioning?
It depends on the site and beacon density. In a simulation for an installation with 100 m spacing, the average deviation was 15 m and the maximum 39 m. Accuracy is confirmed by measurement after installation.
Sources
Let us talk about positioning at your plant
We will show a concept on the outline of your site and buildings: beacon spacing, quantity and scope of work. Book a conversation with the InnerWeb team.
Let's talk