InnerWeb
Skip to main content

Cost of crew idle time after an unexplained refusal

A gate refusal that says only "no" turns into phone calls, a search for the person in charge of training and a crew waiting in front of the gate. A sample calculation for a six-person crew shows a loss of 540 PLN per such event, and 120 PLN when the refusal names the missing item. The plant director gets a concrete difference per event and per month.

420 PLN
saving per event (sample calculation)
Source: sample calculation
5040 PLN
monthly saving at 12 events (sample calculation)
Source: sample calculation

What happens after a refusal that explains nothing

The crew stands in front of the gate, security does not know what is missing, so they call the shift manager, who calls the training department, and the service company coordinator calls his people. Each call takes a few minutes, and during that time six people do not work and do not know whether to turn back or wait.

At a railway workshop the idle time has an extra effect: the rolling stock stands in the hall without work, and the service window, planned for specific hours, shrinks. The cost grows not only by the crew's wages but also by the delay of the inspection.

How a refusal works in InnerWeb

A refusal states what is missing: the name of the training, the name of the qualification or the permit. The refusal notification carries the person, date, place and the missing item, so the shift manager gets the full picture without asking security. Every scan, including a rejected one, is written to the gate log.

The voice alarm tells a missing training apart from a missing permit. In other cases only the refusal signal sounds. Security therefore knows at once whether to send the person to training or to the person who issues the permit.

Cost of one refusal for a crew of six

Cost of one refusal for a crew of sixColumn chart: 540 PLN for a refusal without a reason, 120 PLN for a refusal naming the missing item.0200400600PLNRefusal without a reason: 540 PLN540 PLNRefusal without a reasonRefusal with the missing item named: 120 PLN120 PLNRefusal with the missing item named
Source: Sample calculation based on the assumptions in the Calculation section

Sample calculation: assumptions and result

We assume a crew of six people and a cost of one man-hour of 120 PLN (a sample assumption). Refusal without a reason: 45 minutes of idle time to establish the cause. Refusal that names the missing item: 10 minutes, because it is immediately clear whom to contact.

Without a named item: 6 people times 0.75 hours times 120 PLN is 540 PLN per event. With a named item: 6 people times about 0.17 hours times 120 PLN is 120 PLN. The difference is 420 PLN per event. With 12 such events a month this gives 5040 PLN a month, that is 60 480 PLN a year.

The values are sample figures. A plant with a smaller crew or a shorter stop will count less, a plant with a larger crew or a longer stop will count more.

What the calculation does not show

The calculation counts only the crew's wages. It does not include the cost of delaying the rolling stock inspection, contractual penalties, or the time of security and the shift manager, who also call and search. For the plant director this means the real loss is higher than 540 PLN, so the presented result is conservative.

It also does not count a benefit that cannot be priced: a crew that immediately knows what to complete arrives better prepared next time. The refusal log shows which trainings are most often missing, so the plant can schedule them in advance.

Repair hall scenario: three refusals in one shift

Imagine a shift in which three service companies enter the repair hall: one for brake systems, one for air conditioning and one for trolleys. At the gate one mechanic from each company receives a refusal. In the first case a training on the rules in the hall is missing, in the second a permit to work in the inspection pit, and in the third a qualification to work at height.

When the refusal says nothing, security calls the shift manager three times, and the shift manager searches for the right person three times. When the refusal names the missing item, security directs the first mechanic to training at once, the second to the person issuing the permit, and the third to the coordinator of his company. The other crew members who have passed start work without waiting.

The voice alarm tells a missing training apart from a missing permit, so in two of the three cases security recognises the problem from the signal alone, without looking at the screen. The third, a missing qualification, appears in the text of the refusal. In this scenario the difference between a refusal with a reason and one without is not the minutes of one person, but the smooth running of the whole shift.

How to reduce the number of refusals

The cheapest way is to warn the crew in advance. The company coordinator checks the trainings before departure, and the plant sends the QR code only when the gate lets the guest through on training grounds. As a result most gaps come to light before the gate, not at it.

The second step is to review the refusal log after a month: which trainings and permits repeatedly appear as missing. This is data for a conversation with the service companies and for the training plan.

Example calculation

Calculation: crew idle time after a refusal

Assumptions
ParameterValue
Crew6 people
Cost of one man-hour120 PLN/h
Idle time for a refusal without a reason45 min
Idle time for a refusal with the missing item named10 min
Events a month12 events

Result: Saving of 420 PLN per event, 5040 PLN a month, 60 480 PLN a year.

Note: Sample calculation; it does not include the delay of the rolling stock inspection or the time of security.

Video

Frequently asked questions

Is 120 PLN an hour a realistic rate?

It is a sample assumption. The plant substitutes its own crew rate, and the difference changes proportionally.

Does naming the missing item reduce the idle time to zero?

No. The calculation keeps 10 minutes, because the crew still has to complete the missing element. What is reduced is the time spent looking for the cause.

How does security know what is missing?

The refusal names the missing training, qualification or permit, and the notification carries the person, date, place and the missing item.

Let's talk about the gate in your workshop

We will show the security panel on the example of a rolling stock maintenance depot and discuss how to connect it to your existing access control system.

Let's talk