What the number of replacements per year depends on
The basis of the budget is the number of incidents, which follows from the number of people and the loss rate. A plant employing 500 people with an annual card loss rate of 3 percent handles 15 incidents a year, on average one every 3-4 weeks. Replacements for other reasons, such as wear or a change of position, come on top of this, but here we count only losses.
It is worth calculating the loss rate for a given plant from the loss report register for the last 12 months. The 3 percent figure is an assumption for the calculation. Plants with high turnover, shift work and changing rooms outside the hall usually have a higher rate, while plants with a financial penalty for a lost card often have a lower one, at the cost of less frequent reports.
Item one: the replacement card
The replacement card is the item visible on the invoice. For the calculation we assume a unit price of 30 PLN as an assumption for the calculation, without reference to any specific supplier. At 15 incidents this gives 450 PLN a year. InnerWeb is a software manufacturer that does not sell or install the active cards, readers and label printers, so the card prices are not an InnerWeb price but input data for the plant.
It is worth remembering that the physical block of the card sits with the access control system, not with the attendance and access system. A plant choosing a replacement card therefore does not pay extra for the block itself in the InnerWeb system, only for the medium.
Structure of the annual cost of replacing lost cards
Item two: the temporary QR badge
While a replacement card is issued, the employee can receive a badge with a QR code. The first printing of a label for a person without a badge issues it automatically, and the print page matches the label to the size reported by the printer driver. For the calculation we assume a material cost of 3 PLN per label, which gives 45 PLN a year at 15 incidents.
This item is the smallest, but it has the largest effect on behaviour. An employee who knows that without a card they will get a badge and can start work reports the loss within an hour, not after three days of searching. This shortens the part of the window between loss and block that is described separately.
Does the temporary badge require additional infrastructure?
No, if the plant already runs the security panel and a label printer. The rule of one active badge per person is enforced in the application by a transactional lock, so there is no risk that an employee holds two valid badges from different reports at the same time.
Item three: handling time, which usually dominates
Handling time consists of several short steps: the security desk officer accepting the report, the conversation with HR, the block in the access control system, issuing the replacement card and the entry in the register. For the calculation we assume a total of 60 minutes of work by different people per incident and a labour cost of 80 PLN per hour as an assumption. This gives 80 PLN per incident and 1200 PLN a year.
Handling time is the largest of the three items, at around 71 percent of the whole budget. Cutting it in half, for example through one procedure instead of four separate conversations, saves more than renegotiating the card price.
Total and interpretation
The total in the illustrative calculation is 1695 PLN a year: 450 PLN for cards, 45 PLN for labels and 1200 PLN for handling time. This is a small amount compared with the budget for access control, so a plant should not choose solutions only on the price of replacement. What matters more is whether the procedure shortens the risk window and leaves evidence in the register.
The result also shows that savings on card replacement are secondary. The real benefit of a tidier procedure is shorter exposure and consistent evidence for an audit, not a few hundred PLN a year.
Annual budget for replacing lost cards at a 500-person plant
| Parameter | Value |
|---|---|
| Number of employees | 500 people |
| Annual loss rate | 3 percent |
| Loss incidents | 15 a year |
| Replacement card price (assumption) | 30 PLN |
| Cost of a QR badge label (assumption) | 3 PLN |
| Handling time per incident | 60 min |
| Cost of an hour of work (assumption) | 80 PLN/hour |
Result: Cards 450 PLN, labels 45 PLN, handling time 1200 PLN, total 1695 PLN a year, which is 113 PLN per incident.
Note: Illustrative calculation. The unit prices and the hourly rate are assumptions for the calculation, not an InnerWeb price list or a card supplier's offer. The plant substitutes its own values.
Video
Frequently asked questions
Should the budget include cards replaced for other reasons?
Yes, but as a separate item. This calculation covers only loss, so that it is visible how much losing a card alone costs.
Does the employee pay for a lost card?
That is a decision for the plant and its regulations, which is worth discussing with the legal department. A replacement fee reduces the card cost, but it may delay reports and so lengthens the risk window.
Where to get the real cost of an hour of handling?
From the controlling or HR department. The plant sets an internal hourly rate covering the security desk officer, HR and the access control administrator, and uses it in the calculation.
Plan the card budget together with the procedure
We will help calculate the replacement cost on your plant's data and show how the QR badge and the report register shorten handling time. Book a conversation with InnerWeb.
Let's talk